Studio vs. a 1 Bedroom: Which is Right For You?

By Jared McKinney

Apartment Types

Size, budget, environment, and privacy all come into play when considering which apartment style to choose. Most apartment complexes offer a combination of studios, 1,2, and 3 bedroom units all varying in price and size. If you’re considering renting a studio or a 1-bedroom apartment, but aren’t sure which option to choose, we’re here to help! We’re listing the pros and cons of renting a studio vs 1 bedroom apartment to help make your decision pain-free.  

Studio

A studio apartment offers a compact design that people often find comfortable and cozy. This type of unit usually has an open floor plan where the living, dining, and sleeping areas are combined. Studio apartments tend to be the smallest of apartments that rental properties offer. 

The national average studio apartment measures roughly 600 sq ft. Because studio apartments are small and don’t have separate rooms, they might be better suited for a single resident. However, there are some variations of studio apartments that provide tenants with more space and privacy. 

An alcove apartment is one that has a wall or partition that separates the room into an L-shape. This usually gives it more dimension and a higher sense of privacy. A typical studio does not have this additional wall. A convertible apartment is essentially a studio that has a space specifically allocated for a bed. 

The sleeping area in a convertible apartment isn't completely separate from the living space, but there is a clear designation that leaves some room for creativity. To get a better idea, imagine a medium-sized room with a tiny wall/nook for a bed.

Pros

1. Cost Savings

Although rent varies from one city to another, smaller apartments typically cost less than their larger counterparts. Studio apartments are popular choices because they’re typically less expensive than other options. And we’re not just referring to rent. If you opt-in for a studio apartment, you’ll probably save money on utilities since the space will require less energy.

2. Cleanliness

Generally, smaller apartments are easier to keep clean than a 1-2 bedroom apartment. If you don’t enjoy cleaning this might be an important consideration.

A studio apartment might also be an excellent choice for someone who possesses little furniture and decor. If you're moving into a new place for the first time, you might not have a lot of home goods to decorate with and make the space your own. 

3. Convenient

Studio apartments offer a single room worth of living space. Because of this, a smaller space might push you to get out more often. If you're browsing studio apartments in a busy city like Los Angeles or NYC, chances are they are conveniently located close to shopping, food, and other venues you can easily walk or bike to. 

Aerial floor plan of NYC apartment

In some areas, studio apartments aren’t located in a city and would require a car to get around and visit grocery or shopping stores. This might be something to consider when thinking about how happy you’ll be in this type of space.

Cons

1. Space

Do you have a lot of belongings you carry from one place to another? Well, if you’re moving into a studio apartment, this might be an issue. If a studio apartment has a closet, it won’t be very large. But keep in mind that many studios don’t have a closet.

Also, entertaining guests in a studio apartment is difficult because everything is located within one room. Blurring the lines between your living and sleeping areas may make you or your guests uncomfortable. Consider a bigger space if you want to entertain guests properly.

Do you have a pet? If so, consider how much space your pet requires and how happy they will be living there. Space is a huge factor if you’re thinking about renting a studio apartment and even more so if you plan on bringing your furry friend.

2. Privacy

Because studio apartments don’t have separate bedrooms, there isn’t much privacy. If you’re living by yourself, this might not be a major issue. However, if you’re living with a significant other or a roommate, this might be a point to consider. Especially if you plan on sleeping separately from the person you're living with.

studio apartment

One Bedroom Apartments

To be considered a 1 bedroom unit, the apartment must offer a separate bedroom and bathroom with doors and walls. Although the space is on the smaller end of apartment sizes, a 1 bedroom apartment offers both private and communal spaces. 

Unlike a studio apartment where the bedroom, kitchen, and living space are combined, a 1-bedroom separates the bedroom. In places like New York City where there is less space to build, 1 bedroom apartments are typically smaller than the national average and might combine the kitchen and family room. As of 2018, the average square footage of a 1-bedroom apartment is around 797.

One-bedroom apartments may be a better option if you're passionate or curious about interior design, as the extra space will more likely spend less on utilities and décor. However, if you value the privacy of a separate bedroom, you may opt to spend a little more on it.

If you’re a young professional and you’re moving out on your own, you might find it difficult to afford a 1 bedroom apartment on your own. However, if you can afford rent and would like some extra space, a 1 bedroom might just be a perfect fit. 

Pros

1. Size

Everybody has different needs when it comes to the size of their living space. Because of this, the ideal size of your apartment might not be the same for you as others. For some people, a 1 bedroom apartment doesn’t offer enough space, especially if they have kids or pets. For others, a 1-bedroom apartment is the perfect size - and offers a combination of functionality and cost savings. Size can be a pro or con depending on who you are and your specific situation.

2. Storage

If you find a 1 bedroom apartment with plenty of storage then consider yourself lucky! Typically, these apartments don’t offer more than a bedroom closet and a hallway/storage closet for storage. For some people, this might be plenty of space, for others, it could require decluttering or renting a storage unit.

Cons

1. Size

If you have children, it might be difficult to create a space that gives the necessary amount of privacy in a 1-bedroom apartment - especially if the children are older. On the flip side, if your family prefers sharing a room and staying close, the smaller size might be a suitable fit.

2. Cost

The average price of a 1 bedroom in the US is $1,234.43/month. In some areas like Los Angeles or NYC, with smaller units and higher prices, a 1-bedroom apartment can cost upwards of $4,000/month. Although this might seem expensive, the career opportunities, busy nightlife, diversity, and social scene make the higher monthly rent all the more worth it.

Conclusion

Aerial view of an apartment lay out

Consider what is best suited for your needs when conducting your apartment search. The worst thing you can do is lock yourself into a lease you can’t afford. Take the time to do a thorough search once you determine where you will be living. Be flexible with the area you are living in as renting somewhere cheaper might save you money might only be a few minutes away. Luckily, there are many tools online to help you browse what’s available in your area. Good luck!

Must-Read Rentlingo Content